Skip to content

Tunnelton’s Guthrie Mansion

November 11, 2012

[This article originally appeared in the Bloomington, IN, Herald-Times, Click on any photo to enlarge.]

Built by Alfred Guthrie in 1879, the Italianate home stands on the edge of Tunnelton, Indiana in Lawrence County.

Caring for an old house is a real commitment, a genuine act of love. This is even more the case when the house is question is a notable landmark of Lawrence County: the 1879 Guthrie Mansion in Tunnelton, 25 minutes southeast of Bedford. Annette and Doug Fultz, the new owners of the house, made their purchase five months ago, filled with admiration for both the architecture and the location.

The limestone corner pieces of the house have hand-pecked textures.

“My husband and I lived near downtown Bloomington,” Annette said. “We came down here one day with our dogs and saw the ‘For Sale’ sign. I saw the house, but my husband saw the 130 acres.”

They hesitated before making an offer. Annette had always wanted an ornate Victorian house but the few that still stand in Bloomington were beyond her budget. But when her father came across the Guthrie house on a separate trip of his own and saw that it was still for sale, he nudged her into taking another look.

“My husband and I started thinking seriously about it,” Annette remembered. “We had a lot of ‘what-ifs,’ like what if we got sick, and so on. But we sold our restaurant – Soup’s On – in three days, and our house in two weeks. It was meant to be. And here we are.”

The dining room. All rooms have lofty ceiling and tall windows.

The house was built by Alfred Guthrie, a self-made man who was born into modest circumstances but profited enormously when the railroad came through. (Tunnelton is named for the long railroad tunnel there.) Guthrie opened up a general store which attracted all the folk living for miles around, that being an era in which more people lived in farms than in towns. He prospered enormously, acquired 3000 acres of farmland, built a sturdy brick church for his community as well as the town’s railroad depot, and served as county commissioner, state legislator and president of the Stone City Bank in Bedford.

Supposedly, the house was built when Guthrie and the owner of the bank in Mitchell waged a competition to see who could build the prettiest house.  The Mitchell house was torn down several decades ago, leaving the Tunnelton house as the only relic of the competition.

The hallway has unique wood trim.

Before the Fultzes, the house was owned by Tim Cowden, who was related to the Guthrie family and did much to update the house. Sumptuous bathrooms with gleaming stone tile were added, and the attic was fully finished, which gave the house more than 5000 square feet on three levels. But the rear wing, the old servants’ quarters, was never fully finished, nor was the three-room original brick summer kitchen in back. The old barn with its hand-hewn beams pegged together received new exterior cladding but remained semi-derelict inside.

After Annette and Doug finish fixing up the servants’ wing and the summer kitchen, they have ambitious plans.

“I want to market this as a weekend getaway, with a bed-and-breakfast,” Annette said. “There’s a road on the property that goes all the way back to the river, where there’s a great lookout. People will be able to bring kayaks, or hike. There are several sites where we could build cabins for campers. There will be stalls ready for anyone who brings their horse. There’s the casino, Marengo Cave, Bluesprings Cavern, and Spring Mill Park all fairly close by.”

The house is being furnished with antiques by Annette.

Annette has goats and plans to make goats’ milk soap; she also has a flock of hens and two young pigs destined for bacon next year.

“I’ll have a little antique store, sell eggs and soap, and have a luncheon menu,” she continued. “I don’t expect a lot of people, but you wouldn’t believe the number of people who stop at the front and take pictures.”

The antique shop will be located in the summer kitchen. There will also be an outdoor patio that features a decorative fountain, which will serve as a tea room.  The old barn will be updated and will gain a sizeable deck, suitable for wedding receptions.

The house will undoubtedly attract many admirers who have always wanted to see it up close. The old bricks were made on-site; the exterior corner trim is hand-shaped limestone; the front porch has elaborate cast iron tracery. The cellar is floored with limestone slabs, not a single one of which has settled out of alignment after more than 130 years.

I’ll never forget the sensation of standing on top of the widow’s walk, atop the cupula, and hearing nothing but the soft sighing of the breeze in all directions. No traffic noise, no highways in the distance, no leaf blowers….sheer peace.

It’s a particularly amazing experience to scramble up a ladder and emerge from a hatch on the widow’s walk on top of the cupula. From all sides, all that can be heard is the soft sighing of the breeze in the trees.

“I bring a chair up here all the time, with a book,” Annette said. “It’s my favorite place to be.”

The pace of country life appeals greatly to Annette at this point.

The large cellar is paved throughout with sizable slabs of native limestone. The heavy slabs were set so well that none have shifted or settled after 140 years.

“I never thought we’d leave Bloomington,” she said. “There’s a lot there that I miss. I jogged the B-Line, we lived near downtown. I loved my restaurant, and the shopping. But since I moved out here, I have never been happier.”

From → Houses

  1. Lindsay permalink

    Love, love, love this house! I remember passing it as a child, dreaming to live there one day! I can’t wait for the B&B to open. I will be there even though it is only 10-15 minutes from my home.

  2. Mary Beth & Don Box permalink

    Hello, Have been hearing wonderful things and after reading your webpage…am anxious to come and see for
    myself! We have a group of women that are wanting to visit the Tea Room also. When it is ready to go..would you please let me know? Would it be this year? Thanks for letting us know!
    Mrs. Mary Beth Box,21 Meadowland Dr., Mitchell,IN.47446. PH# 812-849-6047.

    • I just received an email from Annette, the owner, yesterday….apparently the old mansion is either already open for business now as a B&B, or is poised to open. I will see Annette in early October for another newspaper interview, but in the meantime I will email her and ask about the status and get a phone number. Will let you know! Thanks for writing.

    • They’re open for business! Received this via email from Annette: “They can visit us on face book Guthrie meadows and our web site is Our telephone is (812)849-0519. “

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: